PROTESTERS have condemned Cornwall Council’s decision to approve the controversial Falmouth Docks expansion scheme, saying this is “far from the end of the story”.

Members of the strategic planning committee gave their approval to the plans yesterday morning, voting seven to three in favour of works to redevelop and modernise the existing dock infrastructure. These include the demolition of eight buildings, partial demolition of existing wharf structures and the construction of new ones, and a new area to build floating offshore windfarms (FLOW).

Falmouth residents opposed to the plans gathered in large numbers outside County Hall ahead of the meeting, which they observed from the public gallery. They condemned the decision, saying that it failed to take account of serious risks to the local environment and to the health and wellbeing of their community.

Fay Locke, of local residents’ group Stop the Dredge, said: “We’re obviously disappointed the planning committee has failed to take on board the very detailed evidence showing why these plans could do so much damage. We’re grateful to those councillors who did their best to point out why more scrutiny and tougher conditions on the application were urgently needed.

“But this is very far from being the end of the story. The Marine Management Organisation (MMO) has still not approved the dredge that is the most damaging aspect of the scheme, We hope it will bear in mind its statutory duty to protect the marine environment, and the extensive expert evidence warning of the dangers of the dredge being carried out as proposed.”

She continued: “We’ve been advised that the many serious flaws in the developers’ application may give strong grounds for a legal challenge. We hope it does not have to come to that.”

Cornwall Wildlife Trust, local fishers and independent scientists all fear the dredge could do severe damage to the unique marine ecosystem of the Carrick Roads, to the Fal and Helford Special Area of Conservation, and to local fisheries.

The committee heard from environmental data scientist Dr Tim Hughes about what he described as “serious issues and omissions” in the application that were not addressed in the Council planning officer’s report.

“We all want to see the Docks modernised, but it’s vital that this is done in a responsible way,” Dr Hughes told members of the committee. “The developer’s application conflicts in multiple ways with policies of the Local Plan, a key legal benchmark for planning authorities, and with other local and national planning guidance. The report’s approval recommendation rested on a judgement that the supposed public benefits of the scheme outweigh the identified harms that such guidance is designed to avoid.

“Our view, supported by extensive scientific and technical research, is that it was only able to do this by significantly underweighting or, in some cases entirely ignoring, these harms – not least in terms of air pollution from cruise ships running their engines in port, greenhouse gas emissions, adverse effects on protected natural habitats and damage to the local fishing and tourism industries.”

After the meeting, Cllr Jackie Walkden (Green Party, Falmouth Arwenack), said: “The approval of this application shows the planning system is broken, but not in the way politicians usually mean.

Find out about planning applications that affect you by visiting the Public Notice Portal.

“It was passed in spite of Cornwall Council receiving a legal opinion that the Environmental Impact Assessment was unlawful. A study by Portsmouth University of the mass die-off in the wake of dredging operations at Teesside concluded we need stronger environmental scrutiny, rather than turning a blind eye to things that could go wrong.”