THE former Mayor of Camborne has blasted a proposal by the town council to increase its share of next year’s council tax by almost 30 per cent. Cllr James Ball said: “We shouldn’t be increasing a precept on our residents while we’re in such a challenging time.”

A proposed increase on the council tax precept for Camborne was discussed at a meeting of the town council’s staffing and governance committee on Monday night.

Following the meeting, Cllr Ball – who sits on both the town council and Cornwall Council – took to social media to slam the move. He said the proposed increase was 28.98%. The council is saying it’s 27.91 per cent.

Cllr Ed Chapman – who succeeded Cllr Ball as Mayor of Camborne – said the council was aiming to improve the town, telling us: “Growth is what pulls people out of poverty.” Both Cllr Chapman and Camborne Town Council have refuted much of what Cllr Ball has said, with the council calling them “misleading allegations”.

Cllr Ball took to Facebook to say: “They quite often say to wait 24 hours before you react to something. I’ve waited 24 hours. I want to talk about Camborne Town Council’s proposed increase for next year, which I have huge issues with.

“During last night’s public session it was debated – if you can call it that – with the proposal that Camborne Town Council will be increasing their precept by 28.98 per cent, which is huge for all the residents of Camborne. I have huge issues and challenged that – I was the only who did challenge.

“I was told it needs to increase because the council has huge costs. When I challenged further, they turned around and said ‘we nearly went bankrupt last year’. I question that because there was nearly half a million pounds underspend. That doesn’t sound like a council going near bankruptcy to me.

“When I challenged further that residents of Camborne should be paying nearly 30% extra, I was told compare it with Falmouth. You can’t compare because the demographic is very different.”

He added: “We shouldn’t be increasing a precept on our residents while we’re in such a challenging time. Everyone is having a challenging time at the moment, from households to businesses. While councils across the country are having to make cuts so we can do our best for residents, Camborne Town Council feels it needs to grow, which I’m a little bit perplexed by.

“I don’t know why we need to grow – there is no reason for Camborne Town Council to grow and no one has asked it to grow.”

Cllr Ball said the precept increase works out at £81 extra per year for a Band E property. He feared the effect on businesses as well as households. “They’re already struggling in the town. People can’t afford to pop into the town because everyone has less and less money.”

The former mayor said he wasn’t against any rise, but he believes it should be around five per cent. “When I was challenging, some of the councillors agreed with what I was saying, but still decided to vote it through.”

He added: “I’m sure there will be comments like ‘we need it for the Town Deal projects’.” Cllr Ball went on to criticise the Town Deal project to restore and transform the historic Grade II listed Basset Centre and adjacent White House into a multi-purpose community and cultural hub called Awenva.

“It’s haemorrhaging money like there’s no tomorrow. I have huge concerns about that project. If somewhere like Heartlands can’t make a go of it, how is Awenva going to make a go of it? It’s going to compete with other spaces within the town, putting them out of business.”

He also criticised some of the salaries and roles at the town council.

“The council has some fantastic titled job roles like head of estates, which come with huge salaries. If you look at the salaries we’ve got there at the moment in the senior leadership team, we’re paying nearly a quarter of a million pounds.

“I have issues with that completely. We don’t need a head of estates at Camborne Town Council – what estates have we got? We’ve got parks and we’ve got Awenva.”

Cllr Ball added he had concerns with the direction the town council is going. “We’re put there by the residents. We’re meant to be your voice but that doesn’t seem to be happening at the moment.”

He asked the residents of Camborne to contact their local town councillor and raise their concerns about paying the proposed extra 28.98 per cent on the council tax precept. He also asked people to attend forthcoming council meetings and raise their concerns about the rise.

“I certainly don’t want to pay 29 per cent extra, mainly because I don’t know what it’s being spent on and I’m part of that town council,” he concluded.

We contacted Cllr Chapman, who was elected Mayor of Camborne in May, to get his reaction to Cllr Ball’s comments. He said that while he appreciated his predecessor’s concerns, he felt some of Cllr Ball’s comments were incorrect and “inflammatory”.

He said: “We are suggesting putting the precept up and know that’s a serious matter, but I think for so long Camborne Town Council has not been brave enough to spend some money to promote Camborne. That’s what we’re trying to do – build capacity to promote Camborne as a place that’s good for business and good for people.

“Cllr Ball says we don’t need growth, but growth is what pulls people out of poverty.”

Addressing Cllr Ball’s question over a need for a head of estates, Cllr Chapman said: “The word estate means building. We have parks and green spaces to maintain, but we also have buildings, for example the toilets in Rosewarne car park, the library and the Awenva project. The head of estates is the head of buildings and parks. It’s not a fancy title.”

What does the mayor think about Cllr Ball’s comments that Awenva is “haemorrhaging money”?

“That is absolutely, totally incorrect,” he told us. “There was a report commissioned by Cornwall Council on the project, which is Town Deal-funded. They have said it’s well managed and it’s going to be produced within timescales and budgets.

“It has been more expensive than expected and we have had to move some money around. Some of the money that was going to be spent on Park Gerry [another Town Deal transformation project] was transferred to Awenva because we can fundraise for Park Gerry.”

Cllr Chapman added that the proposed precept increase would mean an extra £84 per year on a Band D property, though his council has now told us it would be £78.65 per annum. “Most people in Camborne do not live in Band Ds. Quite a lot of people will be on benefits and therefore don’t pay the full council tax,” said the mayor.

He acknowledged the proposed increase “is a concern because people and businesses are struggling at the moment, but sometimes you have to spend to invest to move forward and get better”.

He said that part of the extra investment would go towards working with the business community and other organisations in the town, as well as getting the Awenva building fully utilised.

“I do appreciate that Cllr Ball has concerns about affordability, but Camborne has, for quite a few years, kept the increases artificially low. We’ve seen other towns – like Redruth and Penzance – investing a little bit more and being a bit more vibrant.”

He believed Cllr Ball’s comments were “a little bit inflammatory. I just wish he’d got some of the information a bit more accurate”.

After we spoke to Cllr Chapman, Camborne Town Council contacted us to say Cllr Ball had made some “misleading allegations” it would like to correct.

“Budget proposals are currently being considered that could lead to a 27.91% increase in the precept. Discussions are ongoing and no final decisions have been made. If the 27.91% figure is agreed, Band B payments would rise by an additional £61.17 per annum and Band D by £78.65 per annum. In terms of comparisons with other local towns, Bodmin and Redruth were also offered as examples at the meeting – with Redruth’s precept rise in 2026/27 increasing by 32.89%.

“The town council was never in danger of bankruptcy and nobody at the meeting said that it was. There was an underspend of around £300,000 last year as a result of staffing vacancies. It has been publicly stated on many occasions – the current staffing structure is simply not sufficient to meet the demands of the services the council delivers.

“As an area that has suffered from underinvestment in the past, growth is regarded as key in boosting the local economy and promoting aspiration for the future. “

In terms of Awenva, the town council shared a recent independent review commissioned by Cornwall Council, which states: “Awenva is a strategically important and a transformative regeneration project with a credible route to successful delivery. The project remains deliverable within the current funding envelope and has benefited from compliant procurement, active governance arrangements, and significant progress through the construction phase.”

A spokesperson for the council added: “Awenva is not therefore ‘haemorrhaging funding’ and the clear aim of the development is to encourage greater visitor footfall.

“The size of the Camborne Town Council estate does require a head of facilities and estates to ensure that it is managed effectively. The total cost of £250,000 for six senior officers is not unreasonable given that ten members of staff earning the minimum wage would equate to a similar figure.”

The proposal will now go before Camborne Town Council’s finance committee, which will make a recommendation to the full council. Cllr Chapman says he is happy to answer residents’ questions in person, by phone or email.